And a similar theme throughout, all speaking of a dream that has united all of Jewry, even as some of the facets have sent this nation in different directions. However, when push comes to shove, we are all one. Even if it takes us into overtime, to realize, understand and accept that forever truth.
We are Am Echad, Lev Achad - one nation, one heart. Even as other nations and peoples of the world have an apparent difficulty in accepting that truth, in acceptance of the Promise made to us and documented in the very same Book most religions acknowledge as Holy, a basis in their religions as well as in ours.
The eternal nation, a people of The Lord, has gone through many long and difficult existentially threatening eras of history. Always, no matter how bad it got or even how good it was, there was and always is, that niggling thought, that itch in our psyches that reminded us of one fact. That our stay in any country of the world, even in our eternal Homeland, our ancestral Homeland, no matter who denies that Truth, is not permanent until such time as the world comes to its senses.
Until such a time, there are rules and regularities which encompass our world, our very being. Always, there is that Dream, mostly to be found in western nations, but certainly, as we now live through difficult times, that someday, somehow, we will find a permanent acceptance and even welcome of the Jewish people, in any and all guises, and the gifts they share with the world.
That dream is now to be found in broken shards, sharp edged remnants. It has been found to be flawed and must be trod upon and with steps varying from strong to delicate. Why that persists in being so is an eternal question for which there seemingly have been no answers, certainly not any of trust in permanence.
We know that the final answer will derive from the Lord Above when He has either lost patience with the world or reminded Himself to renew His promise to His people. He is the final decision maker, and so it has always been. And so, it will always be. But, until such time comes upon us, we must do what is best to live in a world whose acceptance, temporary at best, along with its awful ages of harsh derision and Hate, will always batter away at the dream.
I recently came across a quote from Yuri Foreman which tells us clearly of the Dream of the Goldeneh Medina, the Golden Land, America to us. "That's what the American Dream is: you first do the work, then you talk."
How apt is that statement for our lives today? Our self-appointed and/or our chosen leaders have forgotten that missive. They talk without backing, without achievement, without oral commitment graduating into actual deeds and actions. That way leads only to disappointment, disruption and devolution. It leads to a hypocrisy glaring in bright sunlight yet evidently the words addressing this hypocrisy are false, contradictory, and action never follows in its footsteps. Certainly not the actions necessary to delve into a problem and learn what must be done, what steps must be taken in order to bring the problem to a possible and optimistic solution.
It is most disheartening that scores of years after November 9-10, 1938, we have returned to that same JewHatred. To that same premise that Jews and their friends belong nowhere on this earth. They are to be deemed irrelevant yet are accused at the same time of being the cause of all that is wrong in the world. They are to be killed in any and all manner, with any and all matter of humanity and the rules of civilization glaring in their absence. It is a time, once again when the world wishes us to once again "go as sheep to the slaughter” even as the falsehood of that statement and its derivation are ignored.
But the survivors and the descendants of survivors thumb their noses at their haters. Even as we know the battle will be fought on hostile territory. We know from history that we can and always will pull ourselves together and rebuild and thrive and face all problems in optimistic manner for we know that this one nation is an eternal nation and can survive any journey of any length.
So even as the world speaks critically of the Holocaust of the past, who set up memorials and speeches of the Holocaust that was, we do not hear nor see words and actions in which to halt those who would replicate the Holocaust. Those wishing to bring this horror back to the world are encouraged by the moral vacuum of those who claim to mourn what was, yet do nothing to oppose its reincarnation, already clearly seen. Who mourns what was, or so they say, but do nothing, and in fact, even encourage its return.
Why must this seemingly be an eternal truth? An eternal reality in which we relive history ongoing in repetition. Why must the Jewish people always be called upon to "prove" themselves, to face doubts about their loyalty to the nation in they reside? Why must it always be a time of Anatevka, a place where homes have been established and lives have been lived, hard as it must have been and then receive orders to vacate their Anatevkas, wherever they might be. To leave their homes.
Why must the Jews be the people always consigned to the ranks of uncertainty? Walk on crumbling perilous paths and shaky rope bridges in order to survive? And always to be prepared for the emergence of hatred and hostilities from former 'allies and friends' or thought to have been so.
And yet we are also lucky. There is, was, and always will be, our G-d given ancestral homeland, standing there with open arms and welcoming heart to those of the brethren returning. Even more so these days as we have seen the past, seen the past edging to the present, we categorically refuse to allow it to cross all borders and move into the future.
Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow.
Yes, unfortunately the Past has a tendency to replicate itself, to invade the Present and to disrupt Tomorrow.
However, it must be recalled and remind all that that is not necessarily a must. We know and have done so many times to halt, even reverse, if only for a time, the poisons of the past, cleanse them from the present, and deny them a place in the future.
We have done so many times, and we'll continue to do so no matter how many times the evil within some people come to the fore.
We are a people knowing of the perils of a long road and are impatient to reach our destination, but always with the will and the power and the knowledge with which to beat back all those would deny us. All those who espouse Hate.
So it has been.
So it sadly continues to be so.
But so it will not remain in that which is to be.
Am Yisroel Chai!!