I hate to bust your bubble, but you are most definitely not what you claim to be. And actually, I'm not sorry to bust your bubble. There's something very wrong here. Speaking in mameh lashon" words that are very clear to those who would deny them though the label sticks. and the meaning is clear.
What you and people seem to forget is that once a Jew, always a Jew, a profoundly deep privilege. It often demands a great price for that privilege and too often, throughout history there have always been those among the nation who refuse the burden of this privilege. Perhaps it frightens them. Perhaps they feel that this designation "Jew" separates them from the rest of society. We can discuss all day long this in a waste of time.There are always people, weak of nature, weak of pride who turn away from the word Jew. Yet even as they refuse their "Jewishness" in the very next sentence or even the one prior to it, they reclaim it in a twisted manner.
From the time of the Exodus, when some of these enslaved Jewish people expressed an intention to remain mired in their slavery. From the traveling group who instigated and aroused negativity and doubt among the Nation. To those who did not trust, despite all they had seen and knew, that their Lord would not desert them.
In fact, who had not deserted them but rather supported them and guided and guarded them, with problems arising from those who had not the faith necessary to remain committed and trusting of their Guardian. Almost constantly throughout the ages, there appeared to be at least one person, or groups of people, who felt comfortable denying their identity or shifting it so that it was almost unrecognizable. Then, if it was an advantage, politically, economically, pulling it out of the closet, but always sure and definite of remaining apart from the general body of the Jewish nation.
So, Mr. Ed Miliband in your oh so proud position as Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs, you are not a proud Jew, most definitely NOT!
A proud Jew walks tall, erect and proud, not hiding nor downplaying his Jewishness. walks with his head erect. Eyes and ears and mind open and clear. Ever ready to defend his people and contribute to their wellbeing.
It is the Jew who recognizes the importance of Israel and the very personal acts of salvation and rescue it has provided for those in need, for those who are oppressed in other lands of the world. For those who KNOW that having a Jewish state, the land of Israel is critical. For those who have taken to heart, through all the centuries, all the tragedies, all the prayers and reminders and promises and exhortations to return. To return to our Homeland. To help build and rebuild countless times, to always have a segment of the nation on that land.
What are you and others like you doing, intending when you falsely, deeply, erroneously, traitorously trash a nation which is a modern-day miracle. It is now on its way in many aspects to indeed becoming a nation holding up a light to other nations of earth. Thus, fulfilling the Promises of the Lord, the threats and punishments and the return to that land of milk and honey - and AI, and chips and literature and culture and research and of course, always with a lending hand when other nations are in need.
No, Ed, my boy, my not so friendly chap. When you trot out your supposed pride in being a Jew, it is only when it suits you politically or economically. To give you a heads up in the filthy game of governmental, political power plays and ploys in that area.
So, instead of paying pride to your nationality and your ethnicity, to indeed acknowledge with pride all that the Jewish nation has accomplished. Despite all the hate and the opposition and the determination to demean, debase, belittle and disappear us from the face of this earth, against all that, how much the Jewish people have accomplished.
And your reaction to all this is to hide, cowering from those who hate Jews, buying in on the lies of centuries, past, present and most probably future. Worse, and most inexcusable of all is that you use that suddenly remembered connection to your personage as a Jew, and use it to further endanger them, the State of Israel, and yes, you dangerous moron, yourself and your children.
The bad people have always managed to find a stranglehold upon the rest of the Jewish people. Forever their evil instincts overpower any good ones that they have, if they have any at all. This ugliness of self-denial of self-abnegation crosses the pond, as you say, into America.
These people too, are to be considered traitors - not thinking properly, not thinking with pride, not thinking with acknowledgment of the truth of the situations besieging and besetting Jews around the world, including our state, Israel. Certainly, they do not understand how dangerous this adoption of the coloration of the liberal is to the people. Why is he dying to jump onto the train of those whose every other word, if not every word, consists of blame and threats against the Jewish people, of which he is one.
When claiming their coloration as liberal, the now false liberals who buy into the hate for Jews, the intense desire and calls for the end of Israel and all who live within, this is what they are protecting and growing round the nation and in fact, round the world. When you, Jeremy Ben-Ami, most certainly NOT a son of his people, boasts that he has raised and will spend $4 million on opposing all Jewish and non-Jewish candidates who support Israel, he is aiding and abetting, empowering the very ones who have called out for your death. Along with the deaths of all Jews, even those who hate themselves, who deny their Jewish blood.
This questioning and complaining that, well, if Israel, if the Jewish people would consider it enough and be grateful for the rather shaky permission of being allowed, non-guaranteed living space within nations of the world, the haters and non-thinkers are dead between the ears. How many times have we even been granted rights and then have them brutally denied once again.
The very book that most other religions follow or base their own religions upon, state that Promise of Hashem to us, His people, His Chosen people. Sometimes not so good to be so chosen, I guess, as we are supposed to serve as exemplary models for others but inevitably, because we are people, subject to errors of thought or behavior, we are not perfect. But we do try, I believe more than any nation.
There is always a learning process. All people and all nations have a process. However, the worst of this learning process is when people refuse to learn from errors and repeat them over and over again.
It is too bad when always,
Yesterday
Today and most probably well into
Tomorrow
we continue to go wrong in some way, and then fail to meet the challenge and go right where we had previously gone wrong. But what we do know, always and forever, that we are not alone and all the human hatred and denial cannot touch the Promises of the Lord.